Skip to main content
  • Sections
  • Search

Center for Strategic & International Studies

User menu

  • Subscribe
  • Sign In

Topics

  • Climate Change
  • Cybersecurity and Technology
    • Cybersecurity
    • Data Governance
    • Intellectual Property
    • Intelligence, Surveillance, and Privacy
    • Military Technology
    • Space
    • Technology and Innovation
  • Defense and Security
    • Counterterrorism and Homeland Security
    • Defense Budget
    • Defense Industry, Acquisition, and Innovation
    • Defense Strategy and Capabilities
    • Geopolitics and International Security
    • Long-Term Futures
    • Missile Defense
    • Space
    • Weapons of Mass Destruction Proliferation
  • Economics
    • Asian Economics
    • Global Economic Governance
    • Trade and International Business
  • Energy and Sustainability
    • Energy, Climate Change, and Environmental Impacts
    • Energy and Geopolitics
    • Energy Innovation
    • Energy Markets, Trends, and Outlooks
  • Global Health
    • Family Planning, Maternal and Child Health, and Immunizations
    • Multilateral Institutions
    • Health and Security
    • Infectious Disease
  • Human Rights
    • Building Sustainable and Inclusive Democracy
    • Business and Human Rights
    • Responding to Egregious Human Rights Abuses
    • Civil Society
    • Transitional Justice
    • Human Security
  • International Development
    • Food and Agriculture
    • Governance and Rule of Law
    • Humanitarian Assistance
    • Human Mobility
    • Private Sector Development
    • U.S. Development Policy

Regions

  • Africa
    • North Africa
    • Sub-Saharan Africa
  • Americas
    • Caribbean
    • North America
    • South America
  • Arctic
  • Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Australia, New Zealand & Pacific
    • China
    • India
    • Japan
    • Korea
    • Pakistan
    • Southeast Asia
  • Europe
    • European Union
    • NATO
    • Post-Soviet Europe
    • Turkey
  • Middle East
    • The Gulf
    • Egypt and the Levant
    • North Africa
  • Russia and Eurasia
    • The South Caucasus
    • Central Asia
    • Post-Soviet Europe
    • Russia

Sections menu

  • Programs
  • Experts
  • Events
  • Analysis
    • Blogs
    • Books
    • Commentary
    • Congressional Testimony
    • Critical Questions
    • Interactive Reports
    • Journals
    • Newsletter
    • Reports
    • Transcript
  • Podcasts
  • iDeas Lab
  • Transcripts
  • Web Projects

Main menu

  • About Us
  • Support CSIS
    • Securing Our Future
Photo: YASUYOSHI CHIBA/AFP/Getty Images
Critical Questions
Share
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Printfriendly.com

Humanitarian Suspensions and the Politicization of Aid in Ethiopia

August 12, 2021

On August 3, 2021, the Norwegian Refugee Council (NRC) and Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) announced that the Ethiopian government had suspended part or all of their operations for three months each, effective July 30. Both organizations have a long-standing presence in Ethiopia, with recent activity centered in Tigray, Ethiopia’s northernmost region and the epicenter of a nine-month conflict. Al Maktoum Foundation, a humanitarian organization working in the education sector, was also suspended, but it is unclear whether the organization was operating in Tigray. The suspension of NRC, MSF, and the Al Maktoum Foundation is a substantial escalation in the Ethiopian government’s targeting of humanitarian operations and a continuation of a broader pattern of aid obstruction throughout the conflict.

Q1: What is the current humanitarian situation in Tigray?

A1: The humanitarian situation in Tigray remains extremely dire with an estimated 5.2 million people (90 percent of the population) in need of humanitarian assistance. Food insecurity and displacement continue to rise amid widespread sexual violence and conflict spillover into Tigray’s neighboring Afar and Amhara regions. As of July 2021, 400,000 individuals were facing catastrophic food insecurity—Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) Phase 5—the largest number of people since the 2011 famine in Somalia, with an added 4 million people facing crisis or emergency levels of food insecurity. Additionally, 47 percent of pregnant and breastfeeding women are acutely malnourished and close to 2 million people have been internally displaced. Both Tigrayan refugees and refugees in Tigray face threats to their well-being. Recently, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) expressed heightened concern for Eritreans in Tigrayan refugee camps; the Ethiopian government described UNHCR as being ill-informed. Despite an additional $149 million in assistance from the United States and additional commitments from Germany and Canada, the humanitarian response remains significantly underfunded with a $284 million funding gap. Without a dramatic increase of food and livelihood assistance, Tigray will remain at risk for famine-like conditions.

Humanitarian organizations face significant bureaucratic and physical access constraints from all parties to the conflict, hindering the timely and safe delivery of aid. The primary bureaucratic access constraint remains the Ethiopian government’s unofficial blockade of Tigray, an “unacceptable” situation, per U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Linda Thomas-Greenfield. Electricity and telecommunications remain cut off, banking services have yet to be restored, and aid workers are facing challenges importing key equipment, such as VHS radio and satellite phones. Aid workers also report lengthy searches at both Addis Ababa airport and road checkpoints.

Violence and insecurity further threaten the delivery of aid and the lives of humanitarian workers. Since November 2020, 12 aid workers have been killed, including three MSF employees in late June 2021. Other workers report being assaulted at checkpoints and having their aid convoys shot at. Rampant misinformation is exacerbating these risks, forcing humanitarian organizations to respond to false claims in real time to protect their workers, operations, and reputation.

Q2: Why did the Ethiopian government suspend MSF, NRC, and the Al Maktoum Foundation?

A2: According to a since-deleted tweet by Ethiopia Current Issues Fact Check, a pro-government website that has been cited by the Ethiopian government, MSF and NRC were reportedly suspended over public messaging concerns and a lack of compliance with certain rules and regulations. The tweet also alleged a lack of proper work permits for employed foreign nationals and the illegal importation of satellite radio equipment, as well as a lack of adherence to Covid-19 protocols by the Al Maktoum Foundation. In separate statements, NRC acknowledged the accusations, noting that the organization was in talks with the relevant authorities to clarify and follow up on any concerns so that its humanitarian work could resume, while MSF was urgently seeking clarification around the reasons for its suspension.

This suspension is emblematic of a broader pattern of aid obstruction and politicization by the Ethiopian government and an attempt at silencing the public communication of humanitarian organizations operating in the region. Despite official statements by the Ethiopian government granting unfettered humanitarian access in Tigray and lengthy humanitarian negotiations between the Ethiopian government and the United Nations, the situation on the ground paints a different picture. This is particularly true for UNHCR and the World Food Program, whose separate access negotiations with the Ethiopian government remain largely unhonored. Both organizations continue to face bureaucratic access hurdles, suggesting that initial claims of breakthroughs on achieving humanitarian access were premature. Additionally, humanitarian flights remain limited, humanitarian workers continue to face verbal attacks, and aid convoys are far below the 100-truck daily threshold that is required to meet current needs.

In July 2021, the Ethiopian government also escalated its attacks on foreign organizations and accused humanitarian workers of delivering equipment to rebel groups. These accusations threaten the safety of humanitarian organizations in the region, who rely on community engagement and perceptions of political neutrality to operate safely and effectively.

Q3: What are the broader implications of these suspensions?

A3: Civilians will suffer. Given the already constrained humanitarian environment, any reduction in the number of aid organizations in Tigray is sure to have significant effects on the civilian population. This includes diminished access to healthcare, nutritional support, education, water and sanitation assistance, shelter, and more—some of the services provided by MSF and NRC. The disruption of these services will likely disproportionately affect women, girls, and other minority groups.

Humanitarian organizations will be put on notice. Humanitarian organizations in the region may find themselves increasingly worried about their own suspensions. While MSF and NRC have remained vocal about the destruction of medical facilities and refugee camps in Tigray throughout the conflict, some humanitarian organizations may now alter their public messaging campaigns or self-censor to avoid facing suspension. This would further contribute to Ethiopia’s closing civic space.

The government will retain control of the narrative. Less eyewitness testimonies make it difficult to get a full and accurate assessment on humanitarian conditions. This was a serious problem at the onset of the conflict when journalists struggled with a government-imposed internet blackout, and it is now exacerbated by the expulsion of foreign journalists. Ultimately, these actions allow the Ethiopian government to retain control of the narrative and inhibit accurate and timely understanding of the ongoing humanitarian needs.

Kelly Moss is a research associate with the Humanitarian Agenda at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington, D.C. Jacob Kurtzer is the director and senior fellow of the CSIS Humanitarian Agenda.

Critical Questions is produced by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), a private, tax exempt institution focusing on international public policy issues. Its research is nonpartisan and nonproprietary. CSIS does not take specific policy positions. Accordingly, all views, positions, and conclusions expressed in this publication should be understood to be solely those of the author(s).

© 2021 by the Center for Strategic and International Studies. All rights reserved.

Written By
Jacob Kurtzer
Director and Senior Fellow, Humanitarian Agenda
Kelly Moss
Media Queries
Contact H. Andrew Schwartz
Chief Communications Officer
Tel: 202.775.3242

Contact Paige Montfort
Media Relations Coordinator, External Relations
Tel: 202.775.3173
Related
Africa, Commentaries, Critical Questions, and Newsletters, Financial Access, Human Rights, Human Security, Humanitarian Access, Humanitarian Agenda, Humanitarian Assistance, Special Initiatives, Sub-Saharan Africa

Most Recent From Jacob Kurtzer

Upcoming Event
Finding a Path Through Quagmire: Humanitarian Access and Coordination in the Sahel
August 23, 2022
On Demand Event
Humanitarian Innovation in Action
July 19, 2022
In the News
'People are starving and thirsty': As the US sends aid to Ukraine, some say it's not flowing fast enough
USA Today | Maureen Groppe, Anna Nemtsova
July 18, 2022
On Demand Event
Report Launch: Localizing Humanitarian Action in Africa
June 15, 2022
Report
Concurrent Crises in the Horn of Africa
By Jacob Kurtzer, Sierra Ballard
June 7, 2022
Interactive report
A woman in Nairobi sews protective clothing while carrying a child on her back.
Localizing Humanitarian Action in Africa
By Mvemba Phezo Dizolele, Jacob Kurtzer
May 27, 2022
On Demand Event
Sustaining Yemen: Ensuring Humanitarian Aid Amid Shifting Conflict Dynamics
May 24, 2022
In the News
How to Vaccinate Behind Enemy Lines
Foreign Affairs | Susanna Campbell, Jacob Kurtzer, Hilary Matfess
May 15, 2022
View all content by this expert
Footer menu
  • Topics
  • Regions
  • Programs
  • Experts
  • Events
  • Analysis
  • Web Projects
  • Podcasts
  • iDeas Lab
  • Transcripts
  • About Us
  • Support Us
Contact CSIS
Email CSIS
Tel: 202.887.0200
Fax: 202.775.3199
Visit CSIS Headquarters
1616 Rhode Island Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036
Media Queries
Contact H. Andrew Schwartz
Chief Communications Officer
Tel: 202.775.3242

Contact Paige Montfort
Media Relations Coordinator, External Relations
Tel: 202.775.3173

Daily Updates

Sign up to receive The Evening, a daily brief on the news, events, and people shaping the world of international affairs.

Subscribe to CSIS Newsletters

Follow CSIS
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

All content © 2022. All rights reserved.

Legal menu
  • Credits
  • Privacy Policy
  • Reprint Permissions