Southeast Asia from Scott Circle: Engaging Southeast Asia: Economic Recommendations for the New Administration
January 17, 2017
Engaging Southeast Asia: Economic Recommendations for the New Administration
The incoming Trump administration will encounter a Southeast Asia region significantly transformed from the one that the previous administration began to work with eight years ago. The region today is an integral part of the larger Asia Pacific that has the opportunity to play a key role in propelling U.S. trade and jobs in the decades ahead. For the United States to snare the full benefits of this region and maintain leadership in broader regional dynamics will require that the new administration develop a strategy that has regional economic engagement at its core.
Southeast Asia provides stellar economic opportunities for U.S. companies, workers, and farmers. Southeast Asian countries collectively make up a $2.5 trillion economic area and are home to 630 million potential customers for U.S. goods and services, creating the third-largest economy in Asia after China and Japan. These countries collectively are also the United States’ fourth-largest goods trading partner, ahead of Japan, with two-way trade in goods between the United States and ASEAN topping $234 billion and supporting over 500,000 jobs in the United States. U.S. direct investment in ASEAN countries, which totaled $226 billion at the end of 2015, exceeds the foreign direct investment in the region from China, Japan, and South Korea combined.
In recent years, the regional trade agenda has been driven by the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), which would link 12 Asia-Pacific economies representing 40 percent of the global gross domestic product. The TPP has been the centerpiece of U.S. economic policy toward the region, and it includes 4 of the 10-member ASEAN grouping (Brunei, Malaysia, Singapore, and Vietnam). Three other ASEAN countries—Indonesia, the Philippines, and Thailand—have expressed interest in joining the TPP, which clearly shows interest in U.S.-promoted economic initiatives.
With TPP implementation now in doubt under the new Trump administration, other regional initiatives have taken on more importance. The ASEAN Economic Community (AEC) launched at the end of 2015 aims to integrate the members of ASEAN into a single zone of production and consumption. Although ASEAN has a way to go before achieving that reality, the AEC may provide a firmer base for “ASEAN-plus” trade arrangements, including the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) that will link ASEAN to six trading partners including China, Japan, and Korea—but not the United States.
To be sure, the United States is facing new challenges in the region, including slowing economic growth and rising economic nationalism. China is using its growing economic clout to exert more influence in the region both militarily—in the South China Sea by building airstrips on reclaimed islands—and economically—by providing trade, credits, and infrastructure construction that will tie it more closely to regional economies. Southeast Asian countries do not want to be pressed to choose between Beijing and Washington, but they do want the United States to serve as a hedge against overdependence on China.
Several countries in the region have undergone government changes in recent months that affect either their economic policymaking or how the United States can engage with them, or both. In the Philippines, a new government led by President Rodrigo Duterte, which took office last June, appears to have adopted an outward-looking economic agenda, but Duterte’s openness to greater cooperation with the United States remains uncertain as he seeks to boost ties with China and Russia. Indonesia, the largest economy in Southeast Asia, is held back economically by a raft of protectionist measures and the government’s flirtation with economic nationalism to protect domestic companies from competition from foreign investors.
Despite significant economic engagement by U.S. companies, there is a strong perception among regional government and business leaders that U.S. economic presence and leadership lag far behind security cooperation. This perception has deepened significantly with negative rhetoric directed at the TPP by both the Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton presidential campaigns. Many Southeast Asian nations believe that Washington does not have a coherent plan to engage the region economically, at a time when most regional governments value getting their economic houses in order above virtually everything else.
With these dynamics at play, the Southeast Asia Program at CSIS teamed up with CSIS’s Simon Chair in Political Economy and Scholl Chair in International Business to convene an Asia Economic Strategy Commission to formulate a reinvigorated strategy for U.S. economic engagement with Asia. The commission, cochaired by Charlene Barshefsky, Evan G. Greenberg, and Jon M. Huntsman Jr., just published its report, Reinvigorating U.S. Economic Strategy in the Asia Pacific: Recommendations for the Incoming Administration. You can read the full report here. The report makes the following recommendations:
1. Articulate a clear vision of the United States as a Pacific power: Starting with the inaugural speech, the new president should make clear to the American people, in words and policies, that the United States is a Pacific power and that robust trans-Pacific exchange is critical to our future prosperity and security.
2. Complete the TPP, and continue working to open markets and strengthen rules in the Asia Pacific: Ratification of the TPP—fixed as needed—is critical to U.S. credibility in Asia and to our role as champions of a rules-based order following Western norms. The new administration should work toward its eventual passage and in the meantime continue to promote liberalization and high-standard rules like those in the TPP.
3. Take action to ensure that the U.S.-China relationship is mutually beneficial: A mutually beneficial U.S.-China economic relationship is strongly in U.S. interests. However, the relationship is currently out of balance. The new administration should continue to pursue cooperation with Beijing where possible, while responding forcefully to Chinese practices that harm U.S. interests.
4. Take action to maintain U.S. technological leadership: America’s comparative advantage in technology is vital to our prosperity and security. In addition to making the right investments in innovation at home, the new administration must work to ensure high, open standards for technology internationally and protect U.S. intellectual property.
5. Bring U.S. strengths to the infrastructure push across Asia: Washington needs a more coherent strategy for U.S. involvement in the current infrastructure investment push across Asia. The strategy should be built around U.S. strengths, including commitment to the rule of law, transparency, and world-leading companies.
6. Update and uphold the Asia-Pacific economic architecture: The new administration should work with partner countries and the private sector to strengthen and streamline economic institutions that support a rules-based order in the Asia Pacific, such the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum. It should also participate more fully in the economic dimensions of ASEAN cooperation.
7. Work with Congress to rebuild U.S. leverage and fully resource U.S. priorities in Asia: The new administration should assess the adequacy of current spending to support U.S. economic priorities in the Asia Pacific and identify where additional investments are needed, review measures available under current law to address unfair economic policies, and work with Congress to enhance U.S. resources and leverage.
8. Build an effective interagency Asia economic team coordinated by the White House: The new administration should update its policymaking apparatus to reflect the critical importance of economic tools in a comprehensive strategy toward the Asia region, and improve coordination across the U.S. government and with stakeholders.
Dr. Amy Searight is a senior adviser and director of the Southeast Asia Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) in Washington, D.C. Murray Hiebert is a senior adviser and deputy director of the program.
Over 150 escape in largest-ever Philippine jailbreak
Some 158 inmates escaped from a jail in the capital city of Cotabato Province in the southern Philippines when it was attacked by around 100 armed militants on January 4. One guard was killed and another injured during the jailbreak. To date, 43 inmates have been recaptured and 8 killed. The Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Fighters, a splinter group of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, are believed to be behind the attack.
Top officials downplay Indonesia-Australia military cooperation rift
Indonesian officials have walked back a January 5 announcement by Armed Forces Commander Gen. Gatot Nurmantyo that military cooperation with Australia would be suspended. President Joko Widodo was reportedly not consulted prior to the announcement, and Security Coordinating Minister Wiranto has clarified that only cooperation on language courses would be suspended. The suspension stems from complaints by an Indonesian officer assisting the Australian military with an Indonesian language program, who claimed the program insulted Indonesia by including materials that supported West Papuan independence and mocked Indonesia’s state ideology.
Myanmar detains police after video of Rohingya beating surfaces online
An online video showing Burmese security forces beating Rohingya villagers during a security operation has provided evidence of violence against the Rohingya related to the ongoing crackdown in Rakhine State. Journalists and aid workers have been denied access to the area, making independent verification of human rights abuses difficult. Four police officers have been detained on suspicion of involvement in the beating, and State Counsellor Aung San Suu Kyi’s office said action would be taken against those who broke police force rules.
Fighting continues to intensify in Myanmar’s Kachin and Shan states
Continuing attacks have been reported in Kachin State and northern Shan State, with rebels reporting increased airstrikes and heavy bombing against ethnic armed groups, threatening the safety of refugees and civilians. The Ministry of Defense in a January 8 report stated that four additional Kachin Independence Army outposts had been seized. The UN’s special rapporteur on human rights in Burma on January 9 was barred from entering previously approved sites in Kachin State where human rights abuses are rumored to be taking place.
Vietnam deports Taiwanese fraud suspects to China
Vietnam on January 2 deported four Taiwanese nationals to China because of their suspected involvement in telecommunications fraud, despite strong objections from Taiwan. The Taiwanese Foreign Ministry claimed that Beijing pressured Vietnam into deporting the suspects to China despite repeated Taiwanese requests to have them returned to Taiwan instead. In 2016, over 200 Taiwanese involved in telecom fraud were deported to China from third countries, including Malaysia and Cambodia.
Philippine president tours Russian warship during Manila visit
Two Russian warships, the destroyer Admiral Tributs and the fleet oiler Boris Butoma, arrived in Manila for a goodwill visit on January 3. Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte toured the destroyer on January 6, and Russian and Philippine officials expressed optimism for future cooperation on military exchanges, visits, and exercises between the two countries. The visit comes a month after Duterte sent his foreign and defense secretaries to Moscow to deepen ties between Russia and the Philippines.
Singapore charges Swiss banker as 1MDB investigation continues
A Singaporean court on January 11 sentenced Jens Sturzenegger, the former manager of Falcon Private Bank’s Singapore branch, to 28 weeks in prison and a $89,000 fine for his role in defrauding Malaysia’s 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) state investment fund. Sturzenegger pleaded guilty to three counts of falsifying financial information and three counts of failing to report suspicious transactions totaling $1.25 billion. Sturzenegger is the fourth person to be jailed, as well as the first westerner and fifth banker charged, in Singapore’s 1MDB investigation.
Singapore blogger seeks asylum in the United States
Amos Yee, an 18-year old Singaporean YouTube personality and blogger, is seeking political asylum in the United States. Yee was convicted of obscenity and served jail time in 2015 after publishing YouTube videos featuring profanity-laced criticisms of Christianity, Islam, and late Singaporean leader Lee Kuan Yew. Yee was taken into custody after arriving in the United States on December 16 and will have the chance to officially file for asylum during an immigration hearing within the next few weeks.
Timor-Leste to terminate controversial oil and gas treaty with Australia
Australia on January 9 agreed to allow Timor-Leste to terminate a 2006 maritime border treaty that affects revenue sharing from the Greater Sunrise oil and gas field in the Timor Sea, which analysts estimate holds $40 billion in reserves. Timor-Leste has sought to terminate the treaty for years, arguing it was unfair due to alleged Australian spying during the negotiations, and took the dispute to an international commission last year. The treaty will be terminated after a three-month notice period, and Australia and Timor-Leste will then renegotiate their maritime boundary with the help of the United Nations.
Chinese Navy makes first submarine visit to Malaysia
A Chinese Song-class diesel-electric submarine and a support ship on January 3 made a port call at Kota Kinabalu in eastern Malaysia’s Sabah State, the first visit by a Chinese submarine to Malaysia. According to an official statement from the Chinese Ministry of National Defense, the submarine stopped in Malaysia on its return from anti-piracy patrols off the coast of Somalia. The visit builds on a November 2015 agreement for the Chinese Navy to make use of the port of Kota Kinabalu, and follows an October visit by three Chinese Navy ships to Port Klang near Kuala Lumpur.
CogitAsia Podcast: Thailand's Royal Succession & Political Future
by Murray Hiebert
The death of longtime Thai King Bhumipol Adulyadej and the succession of his son, King Vajiralongkorn, marks the beginning of a sensitive period in Thai politics entering 2017. Murray Hiebert, Deputy Director of the CSIS Southeast Asia Program, joins the podcast to discuss the legacy of King Bhumipol, assess the status of Thai political institutions, and project what the future holds for the junta government in Thailand…Listen here>>>
Kerry Heads to Vietnam as his Successor Begins Confirmation Hearings
by Murray Hiebert
As secretary of state-designate Rex Tillerson prepares to testify in his Senate confirmation hearings on January 11, his predecessor John Kerry will be departing Washington for his farewell visit to Vietnam. The visit has not yet been announced by the State Department, but it has been confirmed by the Vietnamese Foreign Ministry...Read more>>>