Southeast Asia from Scott Circle: Prayuth’s White House Visit Expected to Kick-start Normalization of Thai-U.S. Relations
September 29, 2017By Murray Hiebert, Senior Adviser and Deputy Director (@MurrayHiebert1), Southeast Asia Program (@SoutheastAsiaDC), CSIS
Thai prime minister Prayuth Chan-ocha’s visit to the White House on October 2 could mark a significant step toward normalizing Thai-U.S. relations, which have been strained since the Thai general toppled an elected government in May 2014. Washington responded by suspending some military aid and downgrading, although not canceling, military exercises, including Cobra Gold, the largest multilateral exercise in Asia.
President Donald Trump invited Prayuth to Washington during a phone call in late April and pressed the Thai leader to curtail Thailand’s trade with North Korea in an effort to pressure Pyongyang to suspend its nuclear and ballistic missile programs. Trump, according to Thai government sources, congratulated the general for restoring political stability in the wake of the coup, a reference to the fact that Thailand had been in the midst of months of disruptive political protests when Prayuth and his troops intervened.
Thai-U.S. relations date back to at least 1833, which makes Thailand the first country in Asia with which Washington had diplomatic ties. Bangkok was a partner with Washington during the Cold War, allowing the U.S. military to use Thai bases to execute the war in Vietnam.
U.S. criticism of Thailand after the coup prompted Bangkok to move somewhat closer to China. The Thai military announced a series of military equipment purchases from China and launched several joint military exercises. In 2015, the two countries held their first-ever joint air force exercises, and in 2016 Thailand held joint military exercises with China at the Sattahip naval base. In January 2017, the Thai military signed a $383 million deal to buy its first Chinese submarine, with orders for two more expected for a total value of $1 billion. And in June, it ordered 34 Chinese armored personnel carriers to complement an earlier order for 28 tanks.
Soon after taking office in January, Trump administration officials said Washington would seek to reinvigorate ties with its two treaty allies in Southeast Asia, Thailand and the Philippines, which for different reasons had fallen onto a rocky patch at the end of the Barack Obama administration.
Prayuth earlier had agreed to visit Trump in mid-July, but the Thais postponed the trip a week out, saying privately that they did not have time to prepare for a successful trip. In August, U.S. secretary of state Rex Tillerson made a five-hour stop in Bangkok, marking the highest-level visit by a U.S. official since the military seized power. U.S. Pacific Command chief Admiral Harry Harris had visited in February as part of the Cobra Gold exercise.
The White House said in an announcement on September 26 that the two leaders “will discuss ways to strengthen and broaden bilateral relations and enhance cooperation in the Indo-Pacific region.” The United States is Thailand’s third-largest source of imports after China and Japan, and U.S. companies have long been among the country’s top investors. The Southeast Asian nation had a $19 billion trade-in-goods surplus with the United States in 2016, prompting the Trump administration to include Thailand on a list of 16 countries targeted for investigation.
If Prayuth borrows a page from the playbooks of the earlier White House visits by the prime ministers of Vietnam and Malaysia, he can be expected to witness the signing of some large Thai business deals with U.S. companies before his meeting with Trump. The Malaysian and Vietnamese leaders were heartedly congratulated by Trump for their deals with U.S. firms during their photo opportunities in the White House.
Senior Thai officers are known to have come window-shopping for additional U.S. military equipment in recent months, prompting speculation that Prayuth may announce some military purchases during his visit. In August, in another signal that the United States was softening its stance toward Bangkok, Washington approved the sale of Harpoon missiles to Thailand following approval in July for the purchase of four Black Hawk helicopters that had been suspended following the coup.
Prayuth’s arrival in Washington can be expected to provoke criticism from human rights groups and some members of Congress, but likely not from the Trump administration, which has downplayed the previous administration’s focus on democracy and human rights. Tillerson has said that U.S. security and economic interests should trump human rights in U.S. relations.
The prime minister will hurry back to Bangkok after his visit to participate in two high-profile events on the Thai political calendar: the cremation later in October of highly revered King Bhumibol Adulyadej, who died almost a year ago; and the coronation of his son, King Maha Vajiralongkorn, widely expected in December. The new king, technically a constitutional monarch, requested changes to the new draft constitution soon after he assumed the throne, demonstrating that he expects to be politically involved.
Prayuth is expected by many analysts in Bangkok to call elections sometime in 2018. Some see the general’s more frequent trips to the countryside in recent months, his opening of a Facebook account, and the ongoing series of expressions of support from political groups around the country as the opening salvo in the election campaign. For the time being, Prayuth has the field to himself because the largest political parties, Puea Thai and Democrat, have been banned from engaging in political activities since the coup.
Prayuth cannot technically run for office because under the rules spelled out in the new constitution drafted by allies of the military he would have had to resign from the appointed legislative assembly by July. Nonetheless, he could still be appointed as an “outside” prime minister if no political party wins a majority in the lower house of parliament in the elections. In that case, Prayuth could be appointed prime minister by the appointed Senate as long as he also gets at least half of the votes in the lower house.
One Prayuth-Trump meeting likely will not heal all the bruised feelings among the Thai political elite, but it can at least make it possible for the United States to compete again with China for influence in this strategically located country at the heart of mainland Southeast Asia.
Murray Hiebert is senior adviser and deputy director of the CSIS Southeast Asia Program.
Thousands protest Duterte, drug war on martial law anniversary
Thousands of Filipinos on September 21—the 45th anniversary of former dictator Ferdinand Marcos’s declaration of martial law—gathered in Manila and other cities to protest Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte’s signature drug war and his threats to impose martial law nationwide. Vice president Leni Robredo warned Filipinos to remain vigilant for signs of “rising tyranny,” saying “if we do not remember the past, we are condemned to repeat it.” The protests follow growing concerns over police misconduct in the execution of the drug war. Metro Manila’s police chief on September 15 ordered that the entire 1,200-member Caloocan City police force be relieved of duty and retrained following the controversial police killing of a teenager in August.
Myanmar defiant amid mounting international pressure over Rohingya crisis
Myanmar state counsellor Aung San Suu Kyi on September 18 condemned “all human rights violations and unlawful violence” in Rakhine State, but refrained from criticizing the Myanmar military, which has been accused by the United Nations of “ethnic cleansing” against the Muslim Rohingya minority. Suu Kyi said action would be taken against all human rights violators and that Myanmar was ready to readmit “refugees from this country,” which may not include the stateless Rohingya. She also invited the international community several times to “join us” in addressing Myanmar’s problems. Myanmar army chief Min Aung Hlaing on September 21 did not include the Rohingya in a call for internally displaced people to return to their homes in Rakhine State.
Malaysia rejects ASEAN chairman's statement on Rohingya crisis
Malaysia on September 24 disassociated itself from an ASEAN chairman's statement on the humanitarian situation in Myanmar’s Rakhine State, with Foreign Minister Anifah Aman calling the grouping’s statement a “misrepresentation of reality.” While the ASEAN statement—issued by the Philippines—condemned “all acts of violence which resulted in loss of civilian lives, destruction of homes and displacement of large numbers of people,” Anifah noted that Malaysian concerns were not reflected in the statement, which did not identify the Rohingya as an affected community. The Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs on September 25 said it respected Malaysia's decision to dissociate itself from the statement and that the Philippines toleration of public dissent demonstrated a “new level of maturity” on the implementation of “ASEAN’s consensus principle.”
Singapore prime minister visits China
Singapore prime minister Lee Hsien Loong on September 20 met with Chinese president Xi Jinping as part of a three-day visit to China to boost ties and explore new areas of cooperation under Beijing's Belt and Road Initiative. Lee and Xi reaffirmed the deep friendship between their two countries and discussed bilateral cooperation in financial, judicial, legal, and defense matters. Lee also met with Chinese premier Li Keqiang, top legislator Zhang Dejiang, and anti-graft czar Wang Qishan during his trip. Lee's visit came after a period of tension in Sino-Singaporean relations resulting from disputes over Singapore's relationship with Taiwan and stance on the South China Sea.
Cambodian prime minister asks U.S. to withdraw Peace Corps
Cambodian prime minister Hun Sen on September 15 called on the United States to withdraw its Peace Corps volunteers in an escalating spat over an alleged U.S. conspiracy to aid Hun Sen’s political opposition. Cambodia on September 14 also suspended cooperation with Washington to find the remains of U.S. soldiers missing in action during the Vietnam War. Cambodia’s actions followed the September 13 announcement of a U.S. travel warning for Cambodia and U.S. visa restrictions on senior Cambodian foreign ministry officials instituted in response to Phnom Penh’s refusal to accept Cambodian nationals deported from the United States.
Indonesian anti-communist mob besieges foundation after attempted forum on 1965 killings
Indonesian police on September 18 clashed with anti-communist protesters besieging the Jakarta offices of the Indonesian Legal Aid Institute Foundation, which was alleged to be harboring a meeting of the long-outlawed Indonesian Communist Party (PKI). The foundation had attempted on September 16 to hold a seminar on Indonesia’s 1965 anti-communist massacre, but police had stopped the event because it lacked a permit. An anti-communist mob subsequently surrounded the foundation’s building—responding to “a hoax or fake news” about a PKI event, according to a foundation statement—and had to be dispersed by police with water cannons and tear gas. Five police were injured in the clash, and authorities on September 19 named seven suspects sought for their involvement in the protest.
Former PetroVietnam chairman faces death penalty for embezzlement
Vietnamese prosecutors on September 14 announced they were seeking the death penalty for Nguyen Xuan Son, former chairman of state-owned oil company PetroVietnam, on charges of embezzlement, mismanagement, and abuse of power. Son is accused of embezzling around $11 million from Ocean Bank, where he was CEO from 2008 to 2010, and directing the bank to make excessive interest payments to favored customers, including PetroVietnam. PetroVietnam in 2009 acquired a $35 million stake in Ocean Bank that was completely written off when the central bank took over the failing bank in 2015. Son’s lawyer on September 17 said his client had just been enforcing executive orders issued by Dinh La Thang, another former PetroVietnam chairman who was recently removed from the powerful Communist Party Politburo.
Yingluck sentenced in absentia, three police detained for allegedly aiding her escape
A Thai court on September 27 sentenced former prime minister Yingluck Shinawatra to five years in prison for negligence in a rice subsidy scheme. Thailand’s deputy prime minister, Prawit Wongsuwan, on September 25 rejected the creation of a special panel to investigate the late August disappearance of Yingluck, urging the public to be patient with the ongoing police investigation. Prawit on September 22 accused the police of helping Yingluck flee Thailand just prior to the verdict in her trial. His accusation was based on the questioning of three Thai police officers detained on September 21 for suspected involvement in Yingluck’s escape. The officers reportedly admitted to arranging Yingluck’s travel to the border with Cambodia in a now-seized Toyota Camry. The officers have not been charged with a crime, as there was no warrant for Yingluck’s arrest when she escaped, and no others have been detained despite Prawit’s claims that the escape plot was ordered by someone in Thailand.
Judge grants stay in 1MDB civil cases as Justice Department pursues criminal investigation
A federal judge in Los Angeles on September 13 granted the U.S. Department of Justice’s request for an indefinite stay in civil forfeiture cases involving assets allegedly purchased with funds misappropriated from Malaysian state investment fund 1Malaysia Development Bhd (1MDB). The judge granted the halt in the asset seizure cases to avoid adversely affecting the prosecution of a related investigation into possible criminal charges against individuals alleged to have laundered 1MDB funds through the U.S. financial system. The delayed civil forfeiture cases involve almost $1.7 billion in assets, the largest action brought under the Justice Department’s Kleptocracy Asset Recovery Initiative. Despite the stay, Red Granite Pictures on September 18 reached an undisclosed settlement with the government to resolve an 1MDB-related asset seizure case involving future royalty rights to three films, including “The Wolf of Wall Street.”
Timor-Leste swears in new minority government
Timor-Leste on September 15 swore in a new government, with Fretilin party leader Mari Alkatiri taking over as prime minister of a minority government after an expected coalition partner withdrew at the last minute. Fretilin—which holds 23 seats in parliament—and its partner Democratic Party—which holds another 7—failed to win the support of the 5-seat Khunto party, leaving the ruling coalition with only 30 out of 65 parliamentary seats. The minority coalition will rely on opposition parties to provide confidence and support on key votes. Alkatiri, who served previously as prime minister from 2002 to 2006, has pledged to maintain good ties with neighboring Australia and Indonesia and to create a better economy, education system, and health system.
CogitAsia Podcast: Myanmar on the Brink
By CogitAsia Staff
In this episode we discuss the complicated political picture in Myanmar for Aung San Suu Kyi after 18 months in office and the humanitarian tragedy in Rakhine state. Former U.S. Ambassador to Myanmar Derek Mitchell joins to dissect what is happening on the ground following his most recent visit to the country in late August. Hosted by Will Colson. Audio edited by Ribka Gemilangsari. Written and produced by Jeffrey Bean. Listen here>>>
A Blueprint for Fisheries Management and Environmental Cooperation in the South China Sea
By the South China Sea Expert Working Group
The South China Sea is one of the world’s top five most productive fishing zones, accounting for about 12 percent of global fish catch in 2015. More than half of the fishing vessels in the world operate in these waters, employing around 3.7 million people, and likely many more engaged in illegal, unregulated, and unreported fishing. But this vital marine ecosystem is seriously threatened by overfishing encouraged by government subsidies, harmful fishing practices, and, in recent years, large-scale clam harvesting and dredging for island construction...Read more>>>
Photo Credit: Etienne Oliveau/Pool/Getty Images