Southeast Asia from Scott Circle: Trump-Najib Meeting Gives Malaysia-U.S. Relations Shot of Adrenaline
September 14, 2017By Murray Hiebert, Senior Adviser and Deputy Director (@MurrayHiebert1), Southeast Asia Program (@SoutheastAsiaDC), CSIS
Malaysian prime minister Najib Razak’s visit to the White House on September 12 has injected new energy into a bilateral relationship that had slipped into a funk during the last two years of the previous U.S. administration. Some of this coolness resulted from Najib’s crackdown on his political opposition and the U.S. Department of Justice launching a corruption investigation into the dealings of a Malaysian state investment fund.
Malaysia, for its part, was stunned when President Donald Trump pulled out of the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), which would have given a boost to Malaysia’s economy and integrated the United States more deeply into Asia’s economy.
But those issues were set aside during the meeting between the two leaders. The two leaders avoided a joint press conference, but Trump during a brief photo opportunity said “We’re talking about trade—very large trade deals. Malaysia is a massive investor in the United States in the form of stocks and bonds.” Trump also credited Malaysia for its strong role in combating Islamic State and other terrorist threats in Southeast Asia, and for helping to put economic pressure on North Korea.
Najib also focused on trade and investment in his pre-meeting remarks, touting a deal between Malaysia Airlines and Boeing to purchase more than $10 billion in aircraft over the next five years. He cited $7 billion in pension fund investments in U.S. infrastructure projects and $400 million in high-tech investments by sovereign wealth fund Khazanah as the type of Malaysian investments in the United States that are intended to increase. And Najib reiterated Malaysia’s commitment to combating terrorism in order to keep both the United States and Malaysia safe from their mutual enemies.
Trump and Najib discussed tensions in the South China Sea, where China, Malaysia, and three other countries have overlapping claims. According to their joint statement at the end of the visit, the leaders called on disputing countries to “refrain from action that erodes trust and confidence and escalates tension, including the militarization of outposts.” As if to signal that Malaysia seeks to carefully balance its ties between Beijing and Washington, a Chinese submarine was visiting a Malaysian port at the time Najib arrived in Washington.
The two leaders also talked about ways to press North Korea over its nuclear weapons program as Trump works to line up Asian countries willing to reduce their economic ties with Pyongyang. Trump said that Malaysia, which earlier had significant business dealings with the regime, “does not do business with North Korea any longer, and we find that to be very important.”
Najib and Trump discussed the need to “end the violence” against the Rohingya Muslim minority in Myanmar and “ensure that humanitarian relief reaches victims immediately,” according to their joint statement.
There was no mention in the leaders’ joint remarks before the meeting about the Justice Department’s ongoing criminal investigation into more than $3.5 billion missing from the 1Malaysia Development Bhd fund, some of which were laundered through American financial institutions. A court hearing into this case is scheduled to begin in Los Angeles a few days after Najib leaves the United States.
Najib, the first Malaysian leader to visit the White House since 2004, probably would have liked to hear Trump tell him that he was ending the investigation, but the Malaysian prime minister will likely be happy if his visit demonstrates back in Malaysia—where he faces elections before August 2018—that the U.S. investigation is really a relatively minor issue and that he can still be welcomed into Trump's Oval Office as an important Southeast Asian leader.
Economically, Najib wanted to get a read on future economic cooperation between Malaysia and the United States. Malaysia was one of the 12 parties to the TPP, which Trump pulled out of in his first days in office. Additionally, Malaysia is one of 16 countries that Trump has threatened to investigate and punish because of their large trade surplus with the United States. Najib was expected in his meeting with Trump to assure the president that Malaysia is exploring ways to reduce the deficit and buy more American products, with the Malaysia Airlines deal with Boeing being a prime example.
U.S.-Malaysia relations had improved dramatically since Najib took over in Malaysia in 2009, shortly after Barack Obama won the presidency in the United States. The two countries stepped up military cooperation as China became more assertive in pressing its claims in the South China Sea. In 2015, Obama became the first U.S. president to visit Malaysia since Lyndon Johnson visited in 1966.
But by the end of the Obama administration, relations had cooled because of Najib's crackdown on the media and political opponents, including throwing opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim back in prison on sodomy charges. With Trump in the White House and his administration's downplaying of human rights and democracy concerns, Najib's handling of the opposition was not likely a focus of the White House meeting.
Two key areas of cooperation between the two countries continued in the final years of the Obama administration and the early Trump administration despite the general overall cooling: counterterrorism and military-to military ties. With the increased threats from Islamic State in Southeast Asia with the return of fighters from Syria and Iraq, Malaysia had stepped up counterterrorism cooperation with the Federal Bureau of Investigation and U.S. intelligence agencies over the past two years.
Trump and Najib also pledged to strengthen defense ties, including in the areas of maritime security, counterterrorism, and information sharing between security forces, according to their joint statement. As China has become more assertive in the South China Sea, Kuala Lumpur has increased military cooperation with the United States, including ship visits and joint exercises. Malaysia is particularly anxious about the Chinese Navy's activities off the coast of Sabah and Sarawak where state-owned Petronas is pumping oil and gas.
Murray Hiebert is senior adviser and deputy director of the CSIS Southeast Asia Program.
Indonesia strikes agreement with Freeport on share divestment
The Indonesian government on August 29 announced that Freeport-McMoRan can apply for a 10-year license extension at its Grasberg gold and copper mine after securing an agreement for the U.S. mining company to divest 51 percent of its shares in its Indonesian subsidiary. The agreement also commits Freeport to convert its existing contract—which expires in 2021—into a Special Mining License, build a second smelter in Indonesia within five years, and invest at least $17 billion in the Grasberg mine by 2031. Freeport will maintain control over operations at Grasberg and will now negotiate with the Indonesian government on the price of the divested shares. Energy and Mineral Resources Minister Ignasius Jonan on September 6 indicated that the divested shares would likely be sold to state-owned enterprises in Indonesia.
Timor-Leste reaches deal with Australia on maritime boundary dispute
Timor-Leste and Australia on August 30 struck a deal “on the central elements of a maritime boundary delimitation” in the Timor Sea, according to a statement by the Permanent Court of Arbitration. Details of the deal will remain confidential until all issues are resolved, but it also included an agreement to address the legal status of the disputed Greater Sunrise gas field and establish a special regime to govern its development and share revenues. The deal is planned to be finalized in October.
Myanmar government under pressure as violence against Rohingya escalates
The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights on September 11 accused Myanmar of conducting “a textbook example of ethnic cleansing” after more than 300,000 Rohingya crossed the border into Bangladesh since late August. The refugees fled after militants of the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army attacked police and border outposts on August 25. The attacks sparked attacks by vigilante groups and a military crackdown that the UN human rights chief said was “clearly disproportionate” amid allegations that security forces have torched Rohingya villages and terrorized civilians to drive out the Rohingya population. The Rohingya declared a month-long cease-fire on September 10, but the Myanmar government refused to reciprocate.
Cambodian government cracks down on opposition and media
Cambodian police on September 3 arrested Kem Sokha, president of the opposition Cambodia National Rescue Party, and charged him with treason on September 5 for allegedly plotting to overthrow the Cambodian government with U.S. support. The U.S. ambassador to Cambodia Bill Heidt on September 12 rejected the allegations and called on the Cambodian government to release Sokha. Radio Free Asia on the same day closed its Phnom Penh office, saying it had been forced to do so by a government that “has no intention to allow free media to operate” before next year’s elections. The Cambodian government previously forced the Cambodia Daily newspaper to close on September 4 on alleged tax violations and shut down the U.S.-funded National Democratic Institute on August 24.
Former prime minister flees Thailand before trial verdict
Former prime minister Yingluck Shinawatra fled Thailand before an August 25 court ruling that could have sentenced her to 10 years in prison for negligence involving a controversial rice subsidy program spearheaded by her government. Senior members of Yingluck’s political party said on August 26 that she had fled to Dubai, where her brother, former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra, has a home. The court responded by issuing an arrest warrant for Yingluck, confiscating her $900,000 bail, and delaying its verdict until September 27. Yingluck had previously been impeached in 2015 for corruption over her role in the rice subsidy program.
Malaysian opposition leaders testify for inquiry into 1990s central bank losses
Anwar Ibrahim, de facto leader of Malaysia’s opposition coalition, on September 7 testified before the Royal Commission of Inquiry regarding foreign exchange losses suffered by Malaysia’s central bank during the 1990s. Anwar, currently serving five years in prison, was finance minister from 1991 to 1998 and was questioned about whether he fully disclosed the extent of the losses to the Malaysian government. Former prime minister Mahathir Mohamad (1981-2003), chairman of the opposition coalition, was present for Anwar’s testimony and will testify before the commission himself on September 18. The inquiry, which began on August 21, is viewed as a means for the Malaysian government to revive scandals from Mahathir’s time in office and weaken the political opposition before elections that must be held by August 2018.
Philippine government "rethinking" approach to drug war after controversial deaths
Philippine presidential spokesman Ernesto Abella on September 7 said the controversial deaths of three teenagers had sparked a "major rethinking" of the government’s approach to the drug war. Abella's statement comes after the body of a 14-year-old boy was found with nearly 30 stab wounds, the third teen involved in a recent spate of extrajudicial killings linked to the drug war. Abella said that investigations into police involvement in the killings and Senate hearings on the drug war indicated that a rethinking of the drug war is under way. The speaker of the Philippine House of Representatives on September 11 alleged that the killing of minors could be an attempt by "drug lords" to sabotage the anti-drug campaign and the following day called the Philippine Commission on Human Rights “useless” after the House of Representatives voted to cut the commission’s annual budget to $20.
Malaysian police claim to have thwarted attack on Southeast Asian Games
The new head of the Royal Malaysia Police on September 5 claimed to have foiled a plot by members of the extremist Abu Sayyaf Group to attack the August 30 closing ceremony of the Southeast Asian Games and August 31 Malaysian National Day celebrations in Kuala Lumpur. The group of two Philippine nationals and six Malaysians was allegedly led by a 25-year-old Philippine national linked to past Abu Sayyaf kidnappings in the southern Philippines; no further details on the attack plan or how advanced it was were provided. The plot was discovered during a series of counterterror operations conducted from July 4 to August 30, which resulted in the arrest of 8 locals and 11 foreigners by the police’s Counter-Terrorism Division.
Vietnam targets central bank and national oil company in graft investigations
The Vietnamese Ministry of Public Security on September 8 charged Dang Thanh Binh, a former deputy governor of the State Bank, with “lack of responsibility” and said he is accountable for $400 million illegally withdrawn by a former chairman of the Vietnam Construction Bank, which was taken over by the central bank in 2015. The charges follow a government report detailing flawed supervision of the banking sector and a refusal to follow anticorruption rules at the central bank. The government’s ongoing anticorruption campaign also hit national oil and gas company PetroVietnam, with four senior officials charged on September 1 for mismanagement of funds invested in Ocean Bank, whose former chairman and CEO are on trial for embezzlement and abuse of power. PetroVietnam’s links to the Ocean Bank graft case had previously brought down former Communist Party Politburo member Dinh La Thang, who was ousted in May 2017 for violations he committed as PetroVietnam chairman from 2009 to 2011.
Singapore declares first female president
Former speaker of parliament Halimah Yacob on September 14 was sworn into office as Singapore’s eighth president and first female president. Yacob—who is ethnically Malay—declared her victory “a proud moment for Singapore, for multiculturalism and multiracialism.” Her victory followed a controversial election process during which presidential hopefuls Salleh Marican and Farid Khan were denied eligibility by the Singaporean Elections Department on September 11, clearing the way for Yacob to claim the post without contest. The president of Singapore is a largely ceremonial position, but holds powers relating to the safeguarding of national financial reserves and the appointment of key personnel in the civil service. Yacob is the first ethnic Malay to hold the office of president since 1970.Photo Credit: Alex Wong/Getty Images