Skip to main content
  • Sections
  • Search

Center for Strategic & International Studies

User menu

  • Subscribe
  • Sign In

Topics

  • Cybersecurity and Technology
    • Cybersecurity
    • Intelligence, Surveillance, and Privacy
    • Military Technology
    • Space
    • Technology and Innovation
  • Defense and Security
    • Counterterrorism and Homeland Security
    • Defense Budget
    • Defense Industry, Acquisition, and Innovation
    • Defense Strategy and Capabilities
    • Geopolitics and International Security
    • Long-Term Futures
    • Missile Defense
    • Space
    • Weapons of Mass Destruction Proliferation
  • Economics
    • Asian Economics
    • Global Economic Governance
    • Trade and International Business
  • Energy and Sustainability
    • Climate Change and Environmental Impacts
    • Energy and Geopolitics
    • Innovation and New Energy Sources
    • Markets, Trends, and Outlooks
  • Global Health
    • Family Planning, Maternal and Child Health, and Immunizations
    • Multilateral Institutions
    • Health and Security
    • Infectious Disease
  • Human Rights
    • Civil Society
    • Transitional Justice
    • Human Security
  • International Development
    • Food and Agriculture
    • Governance and Rule of Law
    • Humanitarian Assistance
    • Private Sector Development
    • U.S. Development Policy

Regions

  • Africa
    • North Africa
    • Sub-Saharan Africa
  • Americas
    • Caribbean
    • North America
    • South America
  • Arctic
  • Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Australia, New Zealand & Pacific
    • China
    • India
    • Japan
    • Korea
    • Pakistan
    • Southeast Asia
  • Europe
    • European Union
    • NATO
    • Post-Soviet Europe
    • Turkey
  • Middle East
    • The Gulf
    • Egypt and the Levant
    • North Africa
  • Russia and Eurasia
    • The South Caucasus
    • Central Asia
    • Post-Soviet Europe
    • Russia

Sections menu

  • Programs
  • Experts
  • Events
  • Analysis
    • Blogs
    • Books
    • Commentary
    • Congressional Testimony
    • Critical Questions
    • Interactive Reports
    • Journals
    • Newsletter
    • Reports
    • Transcript
  • Podcasts
  • iDeas Lab
  • Transcripts
  • Web Projects

Main menu

  • About Us
  • Support CSIS
    • Securing Our Future
Blog Post - Smart Global Health
Share
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Printfriendly.com

Ebola Fear and Stigma – Part 1

November 15, 2014

J. Stephen Morrison, director of the Global Health Policy Center here at CSIS, got my attention when he described the Ebola outbreak as a two-front war: a public health battle in plague-like conditions in West Africa, one, and a communications battle against fear and overreaction in the United States, two. Government officials, wrote Dr. Morrison, “failed to appreciate just how swiftly a small number of Ebola cases in Dallas could ignite fear across the nation, raise the risk of panic, and begin to erode public trust.”

Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, made a similar point at the Washington Ideas Forum at the end of October: “I think what we’re seeing,” he said, “is a catastrophic health crisis in West Africa and an epidemic of fear here.”

By now many of us have our favorite, most outrageous episodes of Ebola paranoia: the teacher placed on leave in Maine after traveling to Dallas; the girl kept out of third grade in Connecticut after a family wedding in Nigeria; the Congressional candidate who suggested a city-wide “no handshakes, no hugs” policy for Dallas; the scams and snake oil cures; and so on.

But the examples quickly veer from the amusing and aggravating to the darker and more disturbing. Even as West Africans in the United States grapple with the toll of a wildfire epidemic in Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone, some are finding themselves subject to stigma, slurs, and harassment here. In one case, two young brothers originally from Senegal were “called ‘Ebola’ by other students, taunted about possibly being contagious and … pummeled by classmates on the playground of Intermediate School 318 in the Bronx.” The Wall Street Journal, reporting on stigma in the workplace and in New York neighborhoods, observes that Liberians in the United States are thus at the nexus of both fronts against Ebola; one 6-year-old Staten Island boy coming home from school is quoted saying, “I don’t want to be Liberian anymore.”

American misunderstanding extends to the geography of the epidemic as well. Google any number of countries on the opposite side of the continent from the epidemic, and you’ll find stories of American misunderstanding and fear: Ethiopia, Kenya (here and here), Rwanda (here and here), Tanzania, Zambia, South Africa (here and here).

Fear doesn’t just produce stigma and xenophobia. It’s also bad for public health. Promoting health, preventing disease, tracking infections, responding to outbreaks—in all its aspects public health is a scientific and technocratic field. At its best, decisions are driven by data, based on evidence of effectiveness; unlike diplomacy or intractable social problems, most decisions in controlling an epidemic need not rely on intuition, ideology, or guesswork. Data-driven policy and fear-driven policy, however, rarely line up. When panic takes hold, people demand action against what scares them, and politicians—who report to the people and have electoral reasons to direct fear and blame against their opponents—are inclined to support drastic but ill-conceived measures. A travel ban, say public health experts including Dr. Fauci, would bring people with Ebola into the United States through alternate routes that make them harder to track, and would interrupt U.S. assistance to West Africa. But that hasn’t stopped 77% of the public and at least 86 members of Congress from supporting one.

At the state level, in fact, travel bans and 21-day quarantines of health workers returning from West Africa are already having an effect. In an unsigned piece published November 10, the editors of The Lancet Infectious Diseases point to quarantines in New York, New Jersey, Illinois, and other states; these knee-jerk measures, they write, “have the potential to discourage volunteering, reduce humanitarian assignments to west Africa, and stigmatise those travelling from affected countries.” The Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals ruled in October that travelers from Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone will be quarantined in their hotel rooms, a decision that kept thirty researchers and practitioners from attending last week’s annual meeting of the American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene in New Orleans. This weekend, when the American Public Health Association comes to the Crescent City for its own annual meeting, it will face the same challenge. The travel ban, by its nature, removes from these conferences the public health experts with the most recent, firsthand experience of the epidemic.

The CDC and other public health experts deem these rash measures unnecessary. The probability of a wide-scale Ebola outbreak in the United States—let alone that any particular person in the United States will contract Ebola—is virtually zero. Yet fear, stigma, and popular demand for these policies persist. In a second post, I’ll turn to the underlying psychology of irrational fear and how public officials can best keep the calm in this and similar episodes.

Media Queries
Contact H. Andrew Schwartz
Chief Communications Officer
Tel: 202.775.3242

Contact Emma Colbran
Communications and Program Manager
Tel: 202.775.3211

More from this blog

Blog Post
U.S.-Japan Dialogue: Strengthening the Partnership on Global Health
By J. Stephen Morrison
In Smart Global Health
July 25, 2017
Blog Post
Yellow Fever in Brazil: The Latest Global Health Security Threat
In Smart Global Health
June 23, 2017
Blog Post
Brazil's Sistema Único da Saúde (SUS): Caught in the Cross Fire
By Katherine Bliss
In Smart Global Health
June 21, 2017
Blog Post
GPEI’s Funding Decline Among Tedros’ Top Challenges as WHO Director-General
By Nellie Bristol
In Smart Global Health
June 9, 2017
Blog Post
Achieving TB Milestones Through Last Mile Delivery in India
In Smart Global Health
May 25, 2017
Blog Post
Training the Informal Health Workforce in India
By Richard Downie
In Smart Global Health
May 22, 2017
Blog Post
What’s to Be Done to End the Opioid Epidemic?
In Smart Global Health
May 19, 2017
Blog Post
New Partnerships Needed after Ebola's Hard Lessons
By J. Stephen Morrison
In Smart Global Health
April 25, 2017

Related Content

Commentary
North Kivu’s Ebola Outbreak at Day 90: What Is to Be Done?
By J. Stephen Morrison, Judd Devermont
November 1, 2018
Commentary
Health Security Downgraded at the White House
By J. Stephen Morrison
June 28, 2018
Commentary
An Ounce of Prevention is Worth a Pound of Cure
By Anna Carroll, Samantha Stroman
October 24, 2019
Commentary
The Spanish Flu a Century Later: 2018 Is Not That Different from 1918
By J. Stephen Morrison, Jonathan E. Hillman
March 9, 2018
Commentary
The Ebola Virus Is Winning in Eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo
By J. Stephen Morrison
September 12, 2019
Report
The World is Coming to Sub-Saharan Africa. Where is the United States?
By Judd Devermont
August 24, 2018
Report
Can Digital Health Help Stop the Next Epidemic?
October 11, 2019
Report
Harnessing Multilateral Financing for Health Security Preparedness
April 3, 2019
Footer menu
  • Topics
  • Regions
  • Programs
  • Experts
  • Events
  • Analysis
  • Web Projects
  • Podcasts
  • iDeas Lab
  • Transcripts
  • About Us
  • Support Us
Contact CSIS
Email CSIS
Tel: 202.887.0200
Fax: 202.775.3199
Visit CSIS Headquarters
1616 Rhode Island Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20036
Media Queries
Contact H. Andrew Schwartz
Chief Communications Officer
Tel: 202.775.3242

Contact Emma Colbran
Communications and Program Manager
Tel: 202.775.3211

Daily Updates

Sign up to receive The Evening, a daily brief on the news, events, and people shaping the world of international affairs.

Subscribe to More CSIS Newsletters

Newsletter Subscription
Follow CSIS
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

All content © 2019. All rights reserved.

Legal menu
  • Credits
  • Privacy Policy
  • Reprint Permissions