Dealing with Canada
Photo: Nhac NGUYEN/AFP/Getty Images
Trade with Canada is once again in the news thanks to Democratic promises in the wake of the elections to repeal Trump’s tariffs on the country. The latest polling data shows that all the tariffs are wildly unpopular, probably because they have become part of the affordability debate, and the ones on Canada are least popular of all. While repeal sentiment is strongest in the border states, it also shows up in states where Canadian parts and components are part of local supply chains, most notably the auto industry, and areas that have been the beneficiaries of Canadian tourism and “snowbirds” who come south for the winter. Once commonly sighted in Florida and Arizona, they have become rare birds indeed.
So, the stage seems to be set for a repeal effort once the new Congress convenes in January and Democrats are in the majority. However, there are several obstacles to success. First, action may prove unnecessary depending on what happens between now and the end of the year. Increased 50 percent tariffs on many Canadian goods are slated to go into effect January 1, which creates an incentive for Canada to make a deal, which was probably the tariffs’ purpose. The election results may also help persuade the U.S. administration that a deal makes political sense. Agreement has been elusive so far, though Canadian prime minister Mark Carney sounded optimistic earlier this month when he noted that the United States was “asking less and offering more,” but he also said the parties were not there yet. If a deal is struck, however, that will take some of the steam out of the repeal debate, and at the very least will make the construction of a congressional coalition harder.
Second, while it has been easy for Democrats to say the tariffs should be removed, they have been vague about precisely which tariffs. Unfortunately, the tariffs Canada would most like to see disappear are the Section 232 tariffs on steel and aluminum, which are the very tariffs a good number of Democrats would like to keep. Remember that Senator-elect Sherrod Brown (D-OH) is returning to the Senate. He has long been a strong supporter of those tariffs. I see no indication he has changed his mind, and I expect others to follow his lead. That may not be a majority, but it will be enough to make Senate passage more complicated, particularly if Republicans decide to unite in resistance; 60 votes will be needed to overcome a filibuster, and Democrats will have at most 56. The Republicans have a larger decision to make in the new year: whether they will simply resist all Democratic initiatives or try to find areas where the two parties can cooperate and produce something. The latter is preferable by far, and a decision on how to respond to tariff repeal might be an early test.
Third, tariff repeal means a revenue reduction, which, in turn, means a search for “pay-fors”—revenue-raising measures that will offset the loss. It is difficult to separate tariff revenue by country in real time, but it appears that in 2025 Canada paid approximately $10 billion in tariffs. The 2026 amount is hard to assess but may be more than that. This is not an insurmountable hurdle, but it will complicate the path of any legislation.
Finally, and most important, Democrats will have to construct a veto-proof majority, because Trump is certain to veto a tariff repeal bill. That means 290 votes in the House and 67 in the Senate, assuming everyone votes. Democrats are short of that in both bodies and will need to rely on Republican defections. My experience on the Hill taught me that getting members of the president’s party to go against him on a veto override vote is extraordinarily difficult. Members are under intense pressure from their own leadership and from the White House to support the president. That can often lead to deals in which the White House doles out goodies to wavering members. A slightly easier path would be to tuck tariff repeal into an unrelated “must-pass” bill such as the defense authorization or an appropriation. That would also attract a veto, but it might attract a larger coalition willing to override.
Thus, the path to victory is complicated despite the popularity of the idea. This is also an opportunity to remind people of the dangers of short-term thinking. Right now, there is a lot of commentary on the dire straits of the Republican Party, but the people writing it off now are the same people who wrote off the Democrats two years ago. The pendulum swings, and it always swings back eventually. A vote on tariff relief for Canada will be an early test of the ability of Democrats to mobilize their troops and demonstrate unity, and it will be an opportunity for Republicans to decide whether they want to break with Trump on some issues or fall on their swords supporting him.
William A. Reinsch is a senior adviser (non-resident) and Scholl Chair emeritus with the Economics Program and Scholl Chair in International Business at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C. He can be reached at [email protected].