White Smoke on USTR; GSP Flounders
Photo: JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images
There is good news to report—last week saw white smoke rising from Wilmington, and a new U.S. trade representative was announced. She is Katherine Tai, currently chief trade counsel for the Trade Subcommittee of the House Ways and Means Committee. It is very unusual for someone to go from Hill staff to Cabinet, but as a former staffer who managed to make it to a somewhat lower level in the executive branch food chain, I’m all for that. It is testimony not only to her competence, but to the good professional relations she has been able to maintain with just about everyone. The one disappointment in the past week was the failure of Republicans who know her, have worked with her, and respect her to say anything about her nomination. If they’re afraid to say anything for fear of irritating President Trump by implicitly acknowledging Biden’s victory, that train has left the station. If they simply can’t bring themselves to say something nice about a Democrat, they’re demonstrating the sorry state of American politics and the depth of division the incoming president must overcome.
I hope their silence does not portend a rocky confirmation process. That would be a sad development both for our politics and for our trade policy. In future weeks, I will talk more about the challenges she faces, and if you want an advance look at that, join me on Thursday, December 17, from noon to 1:30 p.m. Eastern Time for CSIS’s biannual conversation with former U.S. trade representatives. There will be eight of them, and I’m sure they will have a lot to say about Tai and what she ought to do.
Meanwhile, one issue she is dealing with in her current job is renewal of the Generalized System of Preferences (GSP) program. GSP provides for zero tariffs on eligible products from eligible developing countries. It has been around for a long time and has had support from both parties, although for different reasons. Republicans, at least pre-Trump, viewed tariffs as taxes and supported anything that amounted to a tax cut. Democrats have viewed it as an economic development tool that will help lower-income countries grow their economies without the on-budget costs of foreign aid. Since a lot of import-sensitive products like apparel are not eligible, its impact on trade politics is small (as is its economic impact, since the program excludes many items where developing countries would have a comparative advantage).
GSP is set to expire at the end of this year. Reauthorization in the past has often been delayed, usually for process reasons in the Congress unrelated to the program, but it eventually passes with retroactive application. This year, its progress to the president’s desk has been put in question by Democratic proposals to add eligibility criteria to the program, including human rights, rule of law, good governance, and anticorruption.
These are noble goals, but they are also proof that no one is paying any attention to my admonition last week about the perfect being the enemy of the good. There are both short- and long-term implications. Short term, the proposals may derail congressional action, creating uncertainty in the United States and developing countries and costing U.S. importers and manufacturers upwards of $1 billion in annual duties.
One of the arguments against the proposals is timing. They arrived at the end of the Congress, and there is no time to consider them seriously, although they are not new proposals—some of them have been kicking around for years. The reality is that Congress has consistently failed to seriously review the program. Then, when amendments are proposed at the last minute, opponents say there is no time. Each GSP renewal, often only two years or less, is accompanied by a promise to take a real look at it before it expires again, and each time the promise is ignored. The tragedy is that the victims of this failure are the innocent parties—lower-income countries trying to grow their economies. I suspect this year’s episode will play out the same way—the proposed changes will be dropped, and the program will be renewed with promises to take up the amendments next year, only to have nothing happen until a month before the next expiration date.
The long-term issue is, effectively, whether charity should be conditional. GSP offers economic benefits to help lower-income countries grow. The proposed criteria essentially say, “we will only help you grow if you behave the way we want.” There is also the question of their ability to implement and enforce the standards we insist on even if they want to do so. On the one hand, it is our benefit, so we should set the rules. On the other hand, what do we accomplish by setting rules that are both patronizing and unlikely to be met even if they’re agreed to? A better approach is that of the Center for International Private Enterprise (CIPE), which works with the other countries’ private sectors on issues like corruption and gender discrimination to build domestic constituencies for these values and local capabilities for implementing them. I think this bottom-up approach works better than top-down mandates from developed countries. The latter makes us feel like we have done a good thing; the former actually accomplishes something.
William Reinsch holds the Scholl Chair in International Business at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C.
Commentary is produced by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), a private, tax-exempt institution focusing on international public policy issues. Its research is nonpartisan and nonproprietary. CSIS does not take specific policy positions. Accordingly, all views, positions, and conclusions expressed in this publication should be understood to be solely those of the author(s).
© 2020 by the Center for Strategic and International Studies. All rights reserved.